Author Archive

Pittsburgh Pirates: Are They Striking Out in the Search for a New Manager?

The Pittsburgh Pirates confirmed on Thursday that they are in the home stretch of finding their next manager.

After nearly two months of conversations, the team appears to be down to two men to lead the ball club in 2011. 

What should alarm Pirate fans is there are seven other major league clubs who entered the offseason in search of a new manager and none of them have contacted either of the men under consideration on Federal Street.

Neither Texas hitting coach Clint Hurdle, nor internal candidate Jeff Bannister have been contacted by any other major league club for any position, let alone manager.

The Pirates have largely failed in their search to this point. Eric Wedge took the job as Seattle’s new skipper before the Pirates could talk to him a second time. Bo Porter would rather be the third base coach of the last place Washington Nationals than come to Pittsburgh. Carlos Tosca took a job as a bench coach in Atlanta.

John Gibbons preferred to remain a bench coach with Kansas City rather than fly to Pittsburgh for a second interview. It is rumored that Gibbons will make more money on the Royals bench than he could have hoped to make in Pittsburgh.

All of this searching has left the club with a guy who hasn’t managed above AA and hasn’t been a manager at any level since 1998 and one who hasn’t turned up on anyone else’s interview list in two years. Not the sort of thing that is liable to get the fanbase fired up.

The Bucs will sit down with Clint Hurdle this week and then are expected to make their decision over the weekend. There will be no interviews past the former Colorado manager. GM Neil Huntington has run through his list and isn’t interested in drawing the process out any further.

The best guess here is that the job will go to Bannister. The stumbling blocks for outside candidates at this point appear to be both money and organizational makeup. The next manager of the Pittsburgh Pirates is not going to make a ton of money at the job no matter how well he does. The next manager of the Pittsburgh Pirates is also going to have to be willing to allow Huntington to micro-manage the situation to the point of distraction.

Bannister saw how that unfolded last year from the inside out. He saw how it created dissension in the ranks of the coaching staff to the point that Gary Varsho and pitching coach Joe Kerrigan were sent home in midseason. Neither man could drink the Kool-Aid any longer.

Bannister also saw the bizarre defensive schemes forced on manager John Russell from the front office. None of them work and none of them made sense, but Russell was a good solider and did what he was told.

That sort of loyalty and obedience will be required of the next manager, as well. Someone without previous managerial experience on the major league level is more likely to have that within him than another man who has managed in a World Series in this century.

Finding a man willing to take on the mantle of a team that is riding the worst losing streak in the history of the game is a tough enough task. Asking that man to do so while jumping through needless hoops is just asking too much.

Read more MLB news on BleacherReport.com


John Russell Dumped by Pirates, but No Sign of Real Change in Pittsburgh

As expected, the Pittsburgh Pirates showed manager John Russell the door late Monday morning.

No matter the reasons or excuses, you just cannot lose 300 games in three seasons and expect to keep your dugout job in any level of baseball.

General manager Neil Huntington says that the search for a replacement for Russell has already begun in organizational meetings in Bradenton, Florida.

Huntington, who was approved for another season on the job by team president Frank Coonelly late Sunday night, will head the search.

So the guy who thought that Jose Bautista could never hit in the major leagues, Aki Iwamura could, and Matt Capps couldn’t get anyone out now gets to decide who is going to lead this team out of wilderness it has wandered in for the last 18 years.

Not that you need any reason to be pessimistic, but here are a couple: The last manager to leave Pittsburgh with a winning record was Chuck Tanner. That was 1985. The last time the Pirates hired a manager who led them to the postseason was 1986 with Jim Leyland. Yeah, that was last century—24 years ago to be exact.

The Pirates will find someone to hand over the lineup card on April Fool’s Day in Wrigley Field, but with as many as 10 other clubs looking for a skipper, the odds that the Bucs find their man given the present backdrop are not ones that you would take in Vegas.

What can the Pirates offer the next manager? Four really good young position players, no shortstop, no real right fielder, and a pitching staff that woeful does not fully describe.

Add to that no financial ability or willingness to find fixes to any of the above outside of the organization.

We can also tell the next guy that the last manager in the system to win, AA Altoona skipper Matt Walbeck, was shown the door after winning the Eastern League title. Lots of excuses here, but no real reasons.

Oh, and whoever takes the job will be hired by a guy in the last year of his contact who has yet to produce anything that even resembles a winning team in four years. 

Good luck with all of that.

If the madness is ever going to end on Federal Street, if the Pirates are ever going to see the bright side of .500, Huntington is going to have to do something draconian, like hire someone outside of his Pittsburgh-Cleveland orbit with a backbone. He’s going to have to hire someone who challenges decisions, has other ideas, and has a say in the process going forward.

It wouldn’t hurt if he could find someone who actually showed some passion for the game and the organization.

At some point the madness will end at PNC Park. Just don’t count on that being any time soon.

Read more MLB news on BleacherReport.com


Copyright © 1996-2010 Kuzul. All rights reserved.
iDream theme by Templates Next | Powered by WordPress