The Red Sox are purging themselves after blowing their playoff hopes with a huge wild-card lead.
Forget about the most recent World Series wins in 2004 and 2007 that reversed “the curse.”
Forget about all the positive steps the Red Sox have made in the past 10 years.
When a team doesn’t win, the pointed fingers jab in all directions; there’s always someone else to blame.
On your way, Terry Francona. Purge, purge.
New is better. Fresh, unattached, clean, and inspiring. Welcome, Bobby Valentine.
Valentine? He has been chosen as the fresh face in Beantown who will ensure Red Sox fans that wild-card leads will never be blown again?
It seemed as though Valentine’s career as a baseball analyst for ESPN would keep him surrounded by the game without being in the game.
Before getting overly critical of one of baseball’s most trademark people, let’s break it down as to why Valentine isn’t a good fit for the Red Sox.
Managerial Skills: Valentine knows as much as anyone about the game of baseball, which has been demonstrated by the insightful comments he made as an analyst.
However, he’s not the best manager. In his 15 years as a coach in the MLB, Valentine’s record was 1,117-1,072 (a win percentage of 51). He won the NL pennant one time, and never finished first in the division.
It’s hard to gauge a manager’s success because it’s up to players to execute wins; nevertheless, a good manager is able to motivate a mediocre team and lead them to victory.
Coaching in Japan, Valentine led the Chiba Lotte Marines to a Japan Series title, but coaching in the MLB is much different, style-wise.
Volatility: Unlike Boston’s most-recent manager, Francona, Valentine has an explosive personality and isn’t afraid to let people know what’s on his mind.
Boston and its fans will provide Valentine with plenty of feedback—most of which will be negative—from the moment he walks into Fenway Park.
Valentine is semi-prepared for criticism after the bleacher chatter he experienced in New York, but Boston will be his most challenging city to manage in.
But Valentine won’t hesitate to counter any negative criticisms that arise in his first season as Red Sox manager, which will just intensify it all.
Player Relations: Whether it’s due to their dislike of Valentine, or their immense love for Francona, Red Sox players aren’t being very receptive of Valentine. ESPN’s Buster Olney elaborated on the players’ reception of Valentine:
“As Valentine emerged as a managerial candidate, some Red Sox players have been upset; they’ve been grumbling to each other, through texts and phone calls. Maybe it’s because they heard Bobby critique their play on the air. Maybe they haven’t liked his tone. Maybe they haven’t liked his smile. Maybe they’ve heard bad things.”
Whatever the reason may be that the players are not being receptive of Valentine, it’s a problem, not only for team chemistry, but especially with Valentine’s unfiltered personality.
Carl Crawford and Josh Beckett will start off on a bad foot with the 61-year-old manager. As an analyst, Valentine criticized their play.
According to the Boston Herald, Valentine made a snark about Crawford’s outfield play, saying, “I was probably a little faster, at least a half-step faster, than Carl, maybe a full step.”
Of Beckett’s slow-paced pitching approach, Valentine commented, “That’s a half-hour added to this game of him standing around, and us sitting around, watching him do nothing.”
While these aren’t the most offensive things to be said, the cynical light under which the players view Valentine will not set the team off right. Valentine will certainly address these comments with the players, but it’s not going to win him any brownie points in the clubhouse.
Loyalty: This is an extension of Valentine’s volatility. He seems to be unable to maintain his loyalty to his team and the front office.
In his first stint in Japan with the Chiba Lotte Marines in 1995, Valentine was fired due to a personal conflict with the team’s general manager.
Then there was the “Whartongate Affair” in which Valentine allegedly made cynical comments about Mets players and the organization to the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School of Business.
To top off Valentine’s career with the Mets, his incendiary relationship with general manager Steve Phillips caused Phillips to fire Valentine after the 2002 season.
And that’s where Valentine closed his career as a manager in the MLB—fired due to a crumby relationship with a general manager.
So after a 10-year hiatus from the MLB, here he is.
Wrap-Up: Valentine is one of the greatest living figures in baseball. He knows the game better than most and has a true desire to win.
However, his personality is not fit for Boston, and the critique from Bostonians won’t be good unless he lives up to the high expectations of Red Sox fans.
So, in that respect, the fans’ expectations determine all.
He’s a guy with a good sense of humor (who could forget his return to the dugout in disguise with a mustache after being ejected in the 12th inning in 1999?) and a good heart, but he’s not the best fit for Boston.
Welcome to Beantown, Bobby. Don’t get too comfortable.
Read more MLB news on BleacherReport.com